Ghaymah Cloud: V1 vs V2 — Comprehensive Comparison
Generated: 2026-10-22
Based on hands-on testing of both platform versions
Quick Comparison Matrix
| Aspect |
V1 (Console) |
V2 (Deploy) |
Winner |
| Dashboard |
console.cumin.dev |
deploy.ghaymah.systems |
V2 |
| CLI Tool |
❌ None |
✅ gy CLI |
V2 |
| Managed Databases |
❌ |
✅ PostgreSQL |
V2 |
| Object Storage |
❌ |
✅ S3 Buckets |
V2 |
| AI Integration |
❌ |
✅ LiteLLM |
V2 |
| Templates |
❌ |
✅ 22 Templates |
V2 |
| Documentation |
❌ Limited |
✅ Full Docs Site |
V2 |
| Service Mesh |
✅ CoreDNS |
✅ CoreDNS |
Tie |
| Security Headers |
❓ Unknown |
❌ Missing |
Neither |
| GraphQL API |
✅ 49 MCP tools |
✅ 41 Mutations |
Tie |
1. Architecture Comparison
V1 Architecture
V2 Architecture
2. Feature-by-Feature Comparison
Core Features
| Feature |
V1 |
V2 |
Notes |
| Container Apps |
✅ |
✅ |
V2 adds friendly name-based management |
| Static Apps |
❌ |
✅ |
NEW — Dedicated static site hosting |
| Projects |
✅ |
✅ |
Both use Helm chart ghaymah-project |
| Public URL |
✅ |
✅ |
V1: *.hosted.ghaymah.systems, V2: *.hosted.cumin.dev |
| Custom Domains |
❌ |
❌ |
Neither supports custom domains |
| Environment Vars |
✅ |
✅ |
V2 adds is_secret and file_path options |
| Resource Tiers |
t1 only |
t1-t7 |
V2 has 7 tiers |
| App Instances |
1 |
1+ |
V2 supports scaling |
| Health Checks |
❌ |
✅ |
NEW — Port-level health monitoring |
| App Tags |
❌ |
✅ |
NEW — Key/value metadata |
Managed Services (All New in V2)
| Service |
V1 |
V2 |
Details |
| S3 Storage |
❌ |
✅ |
Managed buckets, scoped access keys, key rotation |
| Persistent Volumes |
❌ |
✅ |
Disk that survives restarts, mountable into apps |
| Managed PostgreSQL |
❌ |
✅ |
Production DB with connection URL |
| Secrets |
❌ |
✅ |
Encrypted, write-only key-value store |
| Pull Secrets |
❌ |
✅ |
Private registry credentials |
Developer Experience
| Feature |
V1 |
V2 |
Notes |
| CLI Tool |
❌ |
✅ gy |
Auto stack detection, one-command deploy |
| Tunnels |
❌ |
✅ |
Expose localhost to internet |
| JSON Output |
❌ |
✅ |
--json flag on every CLI command |
| Friendly Names |
❌ UUID-based |
✅ my-api |
No more memorizing UUIDs |
| Live Config Updates |
❌ Redeploy needed |
✅ gy config |
Change env/ports without redeploy |
| App Logs (API) |
❌ |
✅ appLogs |
Programmatic log access |
| Documentation |
❌ |
✅ Full site |
docs.ghaymah.cloud (Starlight/Astro) |
AI & Automation
| Feature |
V1 |
V2 |
Notes |
| GenAI Gateway |
❌ |
✅ LiteLLM |
Multi-model AI access with budget controls |
| AI Assistant |
❌ |
✅ /assistant |
Built-in chat AI in dashboard |
| Store Templates |
❌ |
✅ 22 templates |
One-click deploy for popular apps |
| Workflow Automation |
❌ |
✅ n8n template |
Available via store |
| Monitoring |
❌ |
✅ Grafana template |
Available via store |
Platform & Business
| Feature |
V1 |
V2 |
Notes |
| Teams |
❌ |
✅ |
Multi-user collaboration |
| Billing |
❌ |
✅ |
Payment management, plan upgrades |
| User Plans |
❌ |
✅ |
Free plan: 5 max resources, 1 active app |
| Status Page |
❌ |
✅ |
Public service status monitoring |
| Integrations |
❌ |
✅ |
Third-party service integrations |
3. API Comparison
V1 API (MCP/REST — 49 Tools)
V2 API (GraphQL — 41 Mutations)
Key API Differences
| Aspect |
V1 |
V2 |
| Resource Model |
name, image, port, protocol, subdomain fields |
chart_name, chart_version, values (JSON blob) |
| App Creation |
insert_ghaymah_cloud_resources_one only |
createApp mutation with typed CreateAppInput |
| Data Model |
Flat fields per resource |
JSON values blob (flexible schema) |
| Subscriptions |
None |
WebSocket subscriptions on all tables |
| Auth |
Token-based (custom) |
JWT (Hasura Auth, HS256, 900s expiry) |
| Pagination |
Not visible |
Hasura-standard limit/offset/order_by |
4. Networking Comparison
| Aspect |
V1 |
V2 |
| Internal DNS |
CoreDNS (10.43.0.10:53) |
CoreDNS (Kubernetes cluster) |
| Service Discovery |
<name>.<namespace>.svc.cluster.local |
Same K8s DNS pattern |
| Public Domain |
*.hosted.ghaymah.systems |
*.hosted.cumin.dev ⚠️ |
| Protocol Support |
HTTP, TCP (Redis RESP verified) |
HTTP, TCP |
| TLS |
Yes (Let's Encrypt) |
Yes (Let's Encrypt) |
| Backend Isolation |
HTTP 404 from public (partial) |
Via Hasura RLS + K8s network policies |
| Raw TCP |
Verified (Redis RESP protocol) |
Port-level health checks available |
⚠️ Key Finding: V2 apps are hosted on cumin.dev domain instead of ghaymah.systems, revealing the underlying infrastructure change.
5. Security Comparison
| Security Aspect |
V1 |
V2 |
| Auth Method |
Custom token |
JWT (HS256, Hasura Auth) |
| Token Expiry |
Unknown |
900s (15 min) ✅ |
| IDOR Protection |
Partial (cross-project lateral movement found) |
✅ Row-level security (Hasura RLS) |
| SQL Injection |
Not tested |
✅ Parameterized queries |
| Cross-User Access |
⚠️ Lateral movement possible |
✅ Blocked by user_id RLS |
| Rate Limiting (Auth) |
Not tested |
✅ 429 enforced |
| Rate Limiting (API) |
Not detected |
⚠️ Not detected |
| CORS |
Not tested |
Not fully tested |
| GraphQL Introspection |
N/A |
⚠️ Fully exposed (148 types) |
| Security Headers |
Not tested |
❌ All 5 missing |
| Billing Enforcement |
Not tested |
✅ Server-side enforced |
V1 Security Issues Found (Previous Testing)
- Cross-project lateral movement between tenants
- Backend services accessible from public (HTTP 404 but reachable)
- Raw TCP Redis protocol accessible within mesh
V2 Security Improvements
- ✅ Hasura Row-Level Security prevents cross-user access
- ✅ Auth rate limiting (429 on rapid requests)
- ✅ Billing enforcement prevents free plan abuse
- ⚠️ Still needs: security headers, introspection restriction, API rate limiting
6. Store Templates (New in V2)
V2 introduces a marketplace of 22 one-click deployable applications:
| Category |
Templates |
| Development |
Code Server, WordPress, Memos, DocuSeal, Twenty CRM |
| Database |
PostgreSQL, MariaDB, ChromaDB, Valkey, PgBouncer, MeiliBridge, Hasura GraphQL, Metabase |
| Automation |
n8n, Uptime Kuma |
| Monitoring |
Grafana |
| Productivity |
IT Tools, Mini QR, Stirling PDF |
| Web |
Basic Nginx, WordPress Light |
| Tools |
MCP Demo |
Each template supports:
- Variable substitution (resource tiers, passwords, etc.)
- Multi-resource deployment (app + volume + database)
- Auto-provisioning of dependent resources
7. Summary & Verdict
V2 Improvements Over V1
- 22+ new managed services (S3, PostgreSQL, Volumes, Secrets, etc.)
- CLI-first workflow with
gy tool (auto stack detection)
- AI integration (LiteLLM gateway + AI assistant)
- One-click templates (22 apps in the Store)
- Better security (Hasura RLS, auth rate limiting, billing enforcement)
- Real-time updates (WebSocket subscriptions)
- Full documentation (docs.ghaymah.cloud)
- Teams & billing (multi-user, plan management)
- Developer experience (friendly names, live config, tunnels)
- Status monitoring (public status page)
Preserved from V1
- Kubernetes-based orchestration
- CoreDNS internal service mesh
- Helm chart resource model (ghaymah-project, ghaymah-app)
- Container registry per user
- Hasura GraphQL as data layer
Areas Still Needing Attention
- Missing security headers (5/5 absent)
- GraphQL introspection exposed in production
- API rate limiting not detected on GraphQL endpoint
- Resource counter bug (
current_resources: -14)
- No custom domain support for deployed apps
Comparison generated from hands-on testing of both V1 and V2 platforms
Date: 2026-10-22