Files

9.9 KiB

Ghaymah Cloud: V1 vs V2 — Comprehensive Comparison

Generated: 2026-10-22
Based on hands-on testing of both platform versions


Quick Comparison Matrix

Aspect V1 (Console) V2 (Deploy) Winner
Dashboard console.cumin.dev deploy.ghaymah.systems V2
CLI Tool ❌ None ✅ gy CLI V2
Managed Databases ❌ ✅ PostgreSQL V2
Object Storage ❌ ✅ S3 Buckets V2
AI Integration ❌ ✅ LiteLLM V2
Templates ❌ ✅ 22 Templates V2
Documentation ❌ Limited ✅ Full Docs Site V2
Service Mesh ✅ CoreDNS ✅ CoreDNS Tie
Security Headers ❓ Unknown ❌ Missing Neither
GraphQL API ✅ 49 MCP tools ✅ 41 Mutations Tie

1. Architecture Comparison

V1 Architecture

console.cumin.dev (React SPA)
    └── api.cumin.dev (MCP/REST Backend, 49 tools)
        └── graphql.ghaymah.systems (Hasura GraphQL)
            └── PostgreSQL (internal)
                └── Kubernetes Cluster
                    ├── CoreDNS (10.43.0.10:53)
                    ├── Per-project namespaces
                    └── Kaniko/BuildKit (container builds)

V2 Architecture

deploy.ghaymah.systems (React 19 SPA, Vite)
    ├── auth.ghaymah.systems (Hasura Auth, JWT)
    ├── graphql.ghaymah.systems (Hasura GraphQL)
    │   ├── 15 Queries, 41 Mutations, 22 Subscriptions
    │   └── WebSocket streaming for real-time updates
    ├── genai.ghaymah.systems (LiteLLM AI Gateway)
    ├── status.ghaymah.systems (Status Page)
    ├── logs.ghaymah.systems (Centralized Logging)
    ├── registry.ghaymah.systems (Container Registry)
    ├── cliv2.ghaymah.systems (CLI Distribution)
    ├── docs.ghaymah.cloud (Documentation, Starlight/Astro)
    └── Kubernetes Cluster
        ├── CoreDNS (service discovery)
        ├── Helm Charts (ghaymah-project, ghaymah-app)
        ├── S3-compatible Object Storage
        ├── Managed PostgreSQL
        └── App hosting on *.hosted.cumin.dev

2. Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Core Features

Feature V1 V2 Notes
Container Apps ✅ ✅ V2 adds friendly name-based management
Static Apps ❌ ✅ NEW — Dedicated static site hosting
Projects ✅ ✅ Both use Helm chart ghaymah-project
Public URL ✅ ✅ V1: *.hosted.ghaymah.systems, V2: *.hosted.cumin.dev
Custom Domains ❌ ❌ Neither supports custom domains
Environment Vars ✅ ✅ V2 adds is_secret and file_path options
Resource Tiers t1 only t1-t7 V2 has 7 tiers
App Instances 1 1+ V2 supports scaling
Health Checks ❌ ✅ NEW — Port-level health monitoring
App Tags ❌ ✅ NEW — Key/value metadata

Managed Services (All New in V2)

Service V1 V2 Details
S3 Storage ❌ ✅ Managed buckets, scoped access keys, key rotation
Persistent Volumes ❌ ✅ Disk that survives restarts, mountable into apps
Managed PostgreSQL ❌ ✅ Production DB with connection URL
Secrets ❌ ✅ Encrypted, write-only key-value store
Pull Secrets ❌ ✅ Private registry credentials

Developer Experience

Feature V1 V2 Notes
CLI Tool ❌ ✅ gy Auto stack detection, one-command deploy
Tunnels ❌ ✅ Expose localhost to internet
JSON Output ❌ ✅ --json flag on every CLI command
Friendly Names ❌ UUID-based ✅ my-api No more memorizing UUIDs
Live Config Updates ❌ Redeploy needed ✅ gy config Change env/ports without redeploy
App Logs (API) ❌ ✅ appLogs Programmatic log access
Documentation ❌ ✅ Full site docs.ghaymah.cloud (Starlight/Astro)

AI & Automation

Feature V1 V2 Notes
GenAI Gateway ❌ ✅ LiteLLM Multi-model AI access with budget controls
AI Assistant ❌ ✅ /assistant Built-in chat AI in dashboard
Store Templates ❌ ✅ 22 templates One-click deploy for popular apps
Workflow Automation ❌ ✅ n8n template Available via store
Monitoring ❌ ✅ Grafana template Available via store

Platform & Business

Feature V1 V2 Notes
Teams ❌ ✅ Multi-user collaboration
Billing ❌ ✅ Payment management, plan upgrades
User Plans ❌ ✅ Free plan: 5 max resources, 1 active app
Status Page ❌ ✅ Public service status monitoring
Integrations ❌ ✅ Third-party service integrations

3. API Comparison

V1 API (MCP/REST — 49 Tools)

api.cumin.dev
├── REST endpoints
└── GraphQL (graphql.ghaymah.systems)
    └── insert_ghaymah_cloud_resources_one (main method)

V2 API (GraphQL — 41 Mutations)

graphql.ghaymah.systems/v1/graphql
├── Queries (15): resource, store, plan, genai queries
├── Mutations (41): CRUD for apps, static, postgres, s3, volumes, secrets
└── Subscriptions (22): Real-time streams for all resources

Key API Differences

Aspect V1 V2
Resource Model name, image, port, protocol, subdomain fields chart_name, chart_version, values (JSON blob)
App Creation insert_ghaymah_cloud_resources_one only createApp mutation with typed CreateAppInput
Data Model Flat fields per resource JSON values blob (flexible schema)
Subscriptions None WebSocket subscriptions on all tables
Auth Token-based (custom) JWT (Hasura Auth, HS256, 900s expiry)
Pagination Not visible Hasura-standard limit/offset/order_by

4. Networking Comparison

Aspect V1 V2
Internal DNS CoreDNS (10.43.0.10:53) CoreDNS (Kubernetes cluster)
Service Discovery <name>.<namespace>.svc.cluster.local Same K8s DNS pattern
Public Domain *.hosted.ghaymah.systems *.hosted.cumin.dev ⚠️
Protocol Support HTTP, TCP (Redis RESP verified) HTTP, TCP
TLS Yes (Let's Encrypt) Yes (Let's Encrypt)
Backend Isolation HTTP 404 from public (partial) Via Hasura RLS + K8s network policies
Raw TCP Verified (Redis RESP protocol) Port-level health checks available

⚠️ Key Finding: V2 apps are hosted on cumin.dev domain instead of ghaymah.systems, revealing the underlying infrastructure change.


5. Security Comparison

Security Aspect V1 V2
Auth Method Custom token JWT (HS256, Hasura Auth)
Token Expiry Unknown 900s (15 min) ✅
IDOR Protection Partial (cross-project lateral movement found) ✅ Row-level security (Hasura RLS)
SQL Injection Not tested ✅ Parameterized queries
Cross-User Access ⚠️ Lateral movement possible ✅ Blocked by user_id RLS
Rate Limiting (Auth) Not tested ✅ 429 enforced
Rate Limiting (API) Not detected ⚠️ Not detected
CORS Not tested Not fully tested
GraphQL Introspection N/A ⚠️ Fully exposed (148 types)
Security Headers Not tested ❌ All 5 missing
Billing Enforcement Not tested ✅ Server-side enforced

V1 Security Issues Found (Previous Testing)

  1. Cross-project lateral movement between tenants
  2. Backend services accessible from public (HTTP 404 but reachable)
  3. Raw TCP Redis protocol accessible within mesh

V2 Security Improvements

  1. ✅ Hasura Row-Level Security prevents cross-user access
  2. ✅ Auth rate limiting (429 on rapid requests)
  3. ✅ Billing enforcement prevents free plan abuse
  4. ⚠️ Still needs: security headers, introspection restriction, API rate limiting

6. Store Templates (New in V2)

V2 introduces a marketplace of 22 one-click deployable applications:

Category Templates
Development Code Server, WordPress, Memos, DocuSeal, Twenty CRM
Database PostgreSQL, MariaDB, ChromaDB, Valkey, PgBouncer, MeiliBridge, Hasura GraphQL, Metabase
Automation n8n, Uptime Kuma
Monitoring Grafana
Productivity IT Tools, Mini QR, Stirling PDF
Web Basic Nginx, WordPress Light
Tools MCP Demo

Each template supports:

  • Variable substitution (resource tiers, passwords, etc.)
  • Multi-resource deployment (app + volume + database)
  • Auto-provisioning of dependent resources

7. Summary & Verdict

V2 Improvements Over V1

  1. 22+ new managed services (S3, PostgreSQL, Volumes, Secrets, etc.)
  2. CLI-first workflow with gy tool (auto stack detection)
  3. AI integration (LiteLLM gateway + AI assistant)
  4. One-click templates (22 apps in the Store)
  5. Better security (Hasura RLS, auth rate limiting, billing enforcement)
  6. Real-time updates (WebSocket subscriptions)
  7. Full documentation (docs.ghaymah.cloud)
  8. Teams & billing (multi-user, plan management)
  9. Developer experience (friendly names, live config, tunnels)
  10. Status monitoring (public status page)

Preserved from V1

  1. Kubernetes-based orchestration
  2. CoreDNS internal service mesh
  3. Helm chart resource model (ghaymah-project, ghaymah-app)
  4. Container registry per user
  5. Hasura GraphQL as data layer

Areas Still Needing Attention

  1. Missing security headers (5/5 absent)
  2. GraphQL introspection exposed in production
  3. API rate limiting not detected on GraphQL endpoint
  4. Resource counter bug (current_resources: -14)
  5. No custom domain support for deployed apps

Comparison generated from hands-on testing of both V1 and V2 platforms
Date: 2026-10-22