Files
ghaymah-v2-analysis/reports/GHAYMAH_V2_ANALYSIS_REPORT.md

12 KiB

Ghaymah Cloud V2 Platform — Complete Analysis Report

Generated: 2026-10-22T17:56:00Z
Analyst: Automated Security & Infrastructure Analysis
Target: https://deploy.ghaymah.systems


Executive Summary

This report documents a comprehensive analysis of the Ghaymah Cloud V2 platform, covering infrastructure discovery, API exploration, microservice deployment testing, security posture assessment, and a detailed comparison against the previous V1 version.

Key Findings:

  • V2 is a major evolution with 22+ new managed services and features
  • Security posture is generally strong with row-level isolation, but 5 security headers are missing and GraphQL introspection is fully exposed
  • Free plan limits to 1 active app (enforced server-side)
  • App hosting domain has changed to hosted.cumin.dev (from hosted.ghaymah.systems)
  • GenAI/LiteLLM integration is a notable new addition
  • The platform now supports a CLI-first workflow (gy CLI)
  • 22 one-click templates available in the Store

1. Platform Architecture

1.1 Core Endpoints Discovered

Service URL Status Purpose
Dashboard https://deploy.ghaymah.systems ✅ 200 React 19 SPA (Vite-built)
Auth https://auth.ghaymah.systems ✅ Active Hasura Auth (email/password, JWT HS256)
GraphQL https://graphql.ghaymah.systems/v1/graphql ✅ Active Hasura GraphQL Engine
Gateway https://gateway.ghaymah.systems ❌ 404 API Gateway (not routing)
GenAI https://genai.ghaymah.systems ✅ 200 LiteLLM AI Gateway ("RUNNING")
Status https://status.ghaymah.systems/status/ghaymah ✅ 200 Service Status Page
Logs https://logs.ghaymah.systems/logs ⚠️ 405 Centralized Logging (POST only)
Integrations https://integrations.ghaymah.systems/api ❌ 404 Third-party Integrations
Registry https://registry.ghaymah.systems/v2/ 🔒 401 Private Container Registry
S3 Proxy https://s3-nhost-proxy-83e02743fd61.hosted.ghaymah.systems ❌ 404 Artifact Storage
CLI v2 https://cliv2.ghaymah.systems/install.sh ✅ 200 CLI Installation Script
Docs https://docs.ghaymah.cloud ✅ 200 Documentation (Starlight/Astro v7.3.2)

1.2 Frontend Stack

  • Framework: React 19.0.0 (Vite bundled)
  • Build: index-B3hPiU8x.js + index-MwbzL9Cf.css
  • 28 Routes Discovered:
    • /apps, /apps/:appId — App management
    • /projects, /projects/:projectId, /projects/:projectId/apps/:appId — Project hierarchy
    • /dashboard/*, /dashboard/static-deploy — Dashboard views
    • /genAI — AI assistant
    • /billing — Payment management
    • /tunnels — Localhost tunneling
    • /volumes, /managed-volumes — Storage
    • /secrets, /pull-secrets — Credentials
    • /postgres — Database management
    • /storage — S3 storage
    • /store — One-click templates
    • /integrations — Third-party
    • /simple-deployer — Quick deploy
    • /assistant — AI chat
    • /teams — Team management
    • /user/profile — User settings
    • /login, /signup/:ref_by?, /forgot-password, /reset-password, /verify-email, /onboarding, /overview

1.3 Backend Architecture

React 19 SPA (Vite)
    ├── Hasura Auth (JWT, HS256, 900s expiry)
    ├── Hasura GraphQL Engine
    │   ├── 15 Query types
    │   ├── 41 Mutation types
    │   └── 22 Subscription types (WebSocket)
    ├── LiteLLM (GenAI Gateway)
    ├── Container Registry (per-user)
    ├── S3-compatible Storage (Nhost proxy)
    ├── Helm Charts (ghaymah-project, ghaymah-app)
    └── Kubernetes Cluster
        ├── CoreDNS (service discovery)
        ├── Ingress Controller
        └── Per-user namespaces

2. GraphQL API Surface

2.1 Queries (15)

Query Purpose
ghaymah_cloud_resources List Helm chart resources
ghaymah_cloud_resources_by_pk Get resource by ID
ghaymah_cloud_managed_resources List managed resources
ghaymah_cloud_store List store templates
ghaymah_cloud_user_plans User plan/quota info
ghaymah_cloud_genai_apikeys GenAI API keys
ghaymah_cloud_row_event Event history
authRefreshToken(s) Auth token management

2.2 Mutations (41) — Full API Surface

Category Mutations
Apps createApp, updateApp, deleteApp, listApps, appLogs
Static Apps createStaticApp, updateStaticApp, deleteStaticApp, listStaticApps, createStaticUploadURL, generateStaticConfig
PostgreSQL createPostgresDb, deletePostgresDb, listPostgresDb
S3 Storage createS3Bucket, deleteS3Bucket, listS3Buckets, listS3BucketKeys, deleteS3BucketKey, rotateS3BucketKey
Volumes createVolume, deleteVolume, listVolumes
Secrets createSecret, deleteSecret, listSecrets
Pull Secrets createPullSecret, deletePullSecret, listPullSecrets
Resources insert_ghaymah_cloud_resources(_one), update_*
Managed insert_ghaymah_cloud_managed_resources(_one), update_*

2.3 Key Input Types

# CreateAppInput
input CreateAppInput {
  name: String!        # Friendly name (not UUID)
  image: String!       # Container image
  ports: [AppPortInput] # {name: String!, number: Int!, hostname, health}
  env: [AppEnvInput]   # {name, value, is_secret, file_path}
  mounts: [AppMountInput] # {path, volume_id}
  tags: [AppTagInput]  # {key, value}
  memory: Int          # Default: 512Mi
  cpu: Int             # Default: 256m
  instances: Int       # Default: 1
  ephemeral: Boolean
  hibernated: Boolean
  pull_secret_id: String
  args: [String]
}

# CreateS3BucketInput
input CreateS3BucketInput {
  name: String!
  maxSize: Int!
}

# DBInput (PostgreSQL)
input DBInput {
  name: String!
  dbName: String!
  username: String!
  password: String!
}

3. Store Templates (22 One-Click Apps)

Template Category Description
Code Server development VS Code in the browser
Grafana monitoring Monitoring dashboards
Basic Nginx web Simple web server
WordPress Light web WordPress CMS
IT Tools productivity Developer/IT tools collection
n8n automation Workflow automation
WordPress development WordPress + MariaDB
PostgreSQL database PostgreSQL server
Hasura GraphQL database PostgreSQL + Hasura Engine
Mini QR productivity QR code generator
MeiliBridge database PostgreSQL-MeiliSearch bridge
Memos development Self-hosted memo hub
MariaDB database MariaDB server
Twenty CRM development CRM + PostgreSQL + Redis
Uptime Kuma automation Self-hosted monitoring
Stirling PDF productivity PDF manipulation tool
Valkey database In-memory data store
DocuSeal development Document signing platform
PgBouncer database PostgreSQL connection pooler
ChromaDB database Vector database
Metabase database Business intelligence
MCP Demo tools MCP demo server

4. Security Assessment

4.1 Test Results Summary

# Test Result Severity Details
1 IDOR Protection ✅ SECURE N/A Returns null for foreign resource IDs
2 Unauthenticated Access ✅ SECURE N/A Query root not accessible without auth
3 SQL Injection ✅ SECURE N/A Hasura parameterized queries prevent injection
4 Cross-User Mutation ✅ SECURE N/A Cannot modify resources owned by other users
5 JWT Algorithm ⚠️ HS256 LOW Symmetric algorithm (HS256), consider RS256
6 GraphQL Introspection ⚠️ EXPOSED MEDIUM 148 types fully exposed via introspection
7 Security Headers ❌ MISSING MEDIUM All 5 standard headers missing
8 Rate Limiting (Auth) ✅ ENFORCED N/A 429 returned after rapid auth requests
9 Rate Limiting (API) ⚠️ NOT DETECTED LOW 20 rapid GraphQL requests succeeded
10 Billing Enforcement ✅ ENFORCED N/A Free plan correctly limits to 1 active app

4.2 Missing Security Headers

X-Frame-Options:          MISSING  → Risk: Clickjacking
X-Content-Type-Options:   MISSING  → Risk: MIME sniffing
Strict-Transport-Security: MISSING → Risk: Downgrade attacks
Content-Security-Policy:   MISSING → Risk: XSS
X-XSS-Protection:         MISSING → Risk: Reflected XSS

4.3 JWT Token Structure

{
  "alg": "HS256",           // Symmetric key algorithm
  "iss": "hasura-auth",     // Issuer
  "sub": "6c8a1ce5-...",    // User ID
  "exp": 1792680152,        // 900s (15 min) expiry
  "claims": {
    "x-hasura-allowed-roles": ["me", "user"],
    "x-hasura-default-role": "user",
    "x-hasura-user-id": "6c8a1ce5-...",
    "x-hasura-user-is-anonymous": "false"
  }
}

4.4 Key Security Observations

  1. Row-Level Security: Hasura RLS properly enforces user_id isolation — users cannot access or modify other users' resources
  2. Auth Rate Limiting: The auth endpoint returns 429 Too Many Requests on rapid authentication attempts
  3. GraphQL Introspection: Full schema is exposed, which leaks internal API structure to attackers
  4. Billing Enforcement: Server-side enforcement of free plan limits (1 app max) is properly implemented

5. Deployment Test Results

5.1 Test App Deployment

Service: v2-soc-gateway
Image:   nginx:alpine
Status:  Healthy ✅
URL:     https://v2-soc-gateway-http-f2501454.hosted.cumin.dev
CPU:     256m
Memory:  512Mi
Instances: 1
Response: HTTP 200 (nginx/1.31.7)

5.2 Key Deployment Finding

App URLs now use hosted.cumin.dev instead of hosted.ghaymah.systems
This reveals the V2 platform uses a different hosting infrastructure (Cumin) for the actual app runtime, while the dashboard and APIs remain on ghaymah.systems.

5.3 Free Plan Limitations

  • Maximum 1 active app
  • Attempting to create a second app returns: "payment required: your free app is already running - add a payment method for more"
  • Resource tiers: t1 through t7 available

6. GenAI / AI Integration

  • Engine: LiteLLM (confirmed running at genai.ghaymah.systems)
  • API Keys: Managed via GraphQL (ghaymah_cloud_genai_apikeys table)
  • User Key: Pre-provisioned with key name "GENAI Key for ziad.abd.elgwad2003@gmail.com"
  • Budget: No max budget set (unlimited)
  • Dashboard: Accessible at /genAI route
  • AI Assistant: Separate /assistant route for chat-based AI

7. User Account & Plan Details

{
  "plan_type": "free",
  "current_resources": -14,
  "max_resources": 5,
  "user_id": "6c8a1ce5-4ac3-47ad-8838-64e2a986acf3"
}

Note: current_resources: -14 indicates deleted resources count down below zero, suggesting a counter that decrements on deletion but doesn't properly reset.


8. Recommendations

Security

  1. Enable Security Headers: Add X-Frame-Options, X-Content-Type-Options, Strict-Transport-Security, Content-Security-Policy, X-XSS-Protection
  2. Disable GraphQL Introspection in production (or restrict to admin roles)
  3. Implement API Rate Limiting on GraphQL endpoint (currently unlimited)
  4. Upgrade JWT Algorithm from HS256 to RS256 for better key management
  5. Fix Resource Counter: current_resources: -14 is a potential billing bug

Platform

  1. Consider adding custom domain support for apps
  2. Add multi-region deployment options
  3. Implement webhook notifications for deployment events

Report generated by Ghaymah V2 Analysis Script
Date: 2026-10-22